2014년 12월 7일 일요일

All of Research - Do people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs?

Source:
http://breakingmuscle.com/sports-psychology/escalation-commitment-how-we-justify-bad-behavior


My topic:
Human beings try to justify their behaviors or beliefs


What I hope from this search:
I hoped to get some information why people justify their behaviors even commitment.


Notes:
1. according to the concept of escalation of commitment,
people find ways to reduce their cognitive dissonance and discomfort
(twisted logic used to justify their behaviors)


Final thoughts:
This source is useful for only one information that people find ways to reduce their cognitive dissonance and discomfort. And due to this information, I could know the concept of the cognitive dissonance, and so could use for a research.


















Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-justification


My topic:
Human beings try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


What I hope to learn from this source:
I hope to learn about the psychological theory of why people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs (esp. cognitive dissonance)


Notes:
1. inconsistent with our beliefs(cognitive dissonance) -> people feel the need to justify their beliefs
2. Internal self-justification refers to a change in the way people perceive their actions
3. External self-justification refers to the use of external excuses to justify one's actions.


Final thought:
This source is so useful so that I can understand the psychological effect of self-justification and cognitive dissonance which are necessary for my writing.




















Source:
http://psychology.about.com/od/pindex/f/placebo-effect.htm

My topic:
Human beings try to justify their behaviors and beliefs


What I hope to learn from this source:
I wanted to learn one of example of human self-justification effect that is existing in reality and is affecting human, supported by psychological study.


Notes:
Experiment!!
1. People ate counterfeited drug when they felt sick.
2. Psychologists observed the patients how they would be whether they are getting better or getting worse.
3. As a result, surprisingly, patients got better through they didn't take real drugs!!
4. Therefore, psychologists suggested the idea of Placebo effect, named from one psychologist who took this experiment, if people get better when their mind strongly believe to be so.


Final thought:
Through this effect, I could know that people tend to justify their beliefs and those are also expressed by their behaviors or state.




















This is good pictures from Google images search to understand the Placebo effect.








https://www.google.co.kr/search?q=placebo+effect&newwindow=1&biw=1920&bih=979&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=fqsfVI7jMsvM8gW7_4D4Dw&sqi=2&ved=0CD0QsAQ

















Source:
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rationalism-empiricism/


My topic:
People try to justify their beliefs and behaviors.
(Human minds are able to control our beliefs and behaviors.)


What I hope to learn from this source:
I wanted to learn about the origins of two different arguments about human minds which are called rationalism and empiricism. These are the beginning of my argumentative essay, because they represents main ideas about my topic's two opposite claims.


Notes:
1. empiricism included intuition.
2. Descartes claimed that rationalism is prior to empiricism.


Final thoughts:
I should search philosopher Descartes to examine the truth and probability of his thoughts, because they are conflicting with my opinion.
















Source:
http://www.sparknotes.com/philosophy/descartes/themes.html


My topic:
People try to justify their beliefs and behaviors.
(Human minds are able to control our beliefs and behaviors.)

What I hope to learn from this source:
I wanted to learn about philosopher Descartes to know his ideas toward human beings.


Notes:
1. Descartes believed that human reasons like science.
2. Descartes claimed that rationalism is prior to empiricism.


Final thoughts:
I should quote his words in search of humans beings, because they are conflicting with my opinion.

















<Opening Skinner's Box(스키너의 심리상자 열기) - Lauren Slater>




This book is 'Opening Skinner's Box'.

I read the book before I began to write my argumentative essay, but I could learned lots of psychological experiments from this book.

So, I employed several theories and proved tests to cite on my essay writing.

I post this lecture to let you know why my researches are directly associated with my topic and why I searched only more specific information about some of psychological experiments or effects.

I already got some nice information from this book so I did not wrote from where I got to know some kinds of psychological experiments.

ex) cognitive dissonance












Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forer_effect


My topic:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


What I hope to learn from this source:
I hope to learn about Forer effect (also it is called Barnum effect) that was known to support my thesis.


Notes:
1. psychologist Barnum gathered some experimenters. And experimenters got tests which let them know about their personal characters. Then, the result papers were came out and most attenders recorded that those results are really as same as what they thing they are. However, in fact, all respondents got same result papers. This does not mean that all humans have same personal characters. This means that humans strongly believe the experts' saying and so they justified the results, formative characters to fit with their own characters.
2. I think that this experiment is appropriate to use in my essay, because this proves that humans are not objective rather they are so subjective so that they justify their beliefs, making the results of experts' tests fit with their own ones.


Final thoughts:
People try to justify their beliefs according to Forer(Barnum) effect.




















Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment
Book : Opening Skinner's box - Lauren Slater



My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


What I hope to learn from this source:
I want to learn about human mind in extreme occasion, and about self-reflection of themselves.


Notes:
1. Experts set tests in the condition of prison, real prison. They divided attendants to two groups randomly; one is criminals, and the other is polices. Both were promised to get money when they endure the certain days in prison. In the beginning, both got along well with each other. However, polices started to suppress criminals and so criminals started to be cruel toward polices. Both began to think in the way of what they were selected to: polices or criminals. Eventually, their fought was getting bigger, and this led them to kill each other.
2. I think that this experiment shows that humans justify their positions and behaviors toward others in certain cases.


Final thoughts:
People try to justify their behaviors according to Stanford prison experiment.




















Source:
The Harvard Sampler (book) - Psychology part by Steven Pinker



My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


What I hope to learn from this source:
I hope to find evidences to prove that humans are actually selfish beings.


Notes:
1. The author mentioned 'Ultimatum game' and 'Dictator game'. Ultimatum game shows that humans are sensitive to the responds of other humans and to the reputation which humans would tell to somebody else. This looks like odd, because humans are actually selfish. So he also cited dictator game to show how humans behave without threat from others.
2. This theory exactly shows that human innate minds are actually selfish and they try to get the best advantage in certain cases. So I think I can apply this effect to my topic, saying that humans are so selfish so they would try to justify their behaviors and beliefs when they are in disadvantaged situation like making faults.


Final thoughts:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs according to ultimatum and dictator game.























Source:
감정 독재 - 강준만(Jun-Man Kang)



What I hope to learn from this source:
I want to learn about self-serving bias that affects human life.

Note:
People have their own self-serving biases and they think in egoistic way especially when they are in unfavorable situation or occupation.


Final thoughts:I can use this idea in my main points to argue that humans reason depending on self-serving bias. Therefore, people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs, especially when the situation is disadvantageous to themselves.



















Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-serving_bias
감정독재 - 강준만(Jun-Man Kang)


My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


What I hope to learn from this source:
I hope to know about human selfishness to support my second argumentative essay reason.


Notes:
1. A self-serving bias is any cognitive or perceptual process that is distorted by the need to maintain and enhance self esteem. When individuals reject the validity of negative feedback, focus on their strengths and achievements but overlook their faults and failures, or take more responsibility for their group's work than they give to other members, they are protecting the ego from threat and injury. These cognitive and perceptual tendencies perpetuate illusions and error, but they also serve the self's need for esteem.
I can use this theory in my second reason appropriately to support the idea of human selfishness.


Final thoughts:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs to protect themselves according to the theory of self-serving bias.






















Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissism


My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


What I hope to learn from this source:
I hope to know the story of Narcissus to prove that humans think in the way of protecting selves.


Notes:
1. Narcissus fell into the river and died because he loved himself so much.
2. From this story, people would be able to infer the human self-justification effect and be able to know people will do so to protect themselves from getting hurt with the results of their faults.


Final thoughts:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs according to the effect of Narcissism.






















Source:
http://toolkit.smallbiz.nsw.gov.au/part/8/42/200


My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


Source:
http://toolkit.smallbiz.nsw.gov.au/part/8/42/200


What I hope to learn from this source:
I want to gain some opposite opinions to used them in my refutation part of my essay.


Notes:
Normative model defines that people are rational.
So, people prefer the situations that require less efforts to deal with and choose them which are "good enough".



Final thoughts:
I think this normative model theory is good at refuting my argument but I can find some weak points of this theory. So it will be better for me to use this kind of theory in my refutation part of my essay
























Source:
http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/descriptive-model.html
The Harvard Sampler (Steven pinker - psychology part)


My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


What I hope to learn from this source:
I want to learn about descriptive model which will used to shield my argument from the attack of normative model theory.


Notes:
The descriptive model is how people actually do. It is distinguishable from normative model which is the study of how people ought to do in idealistic way and in rational way.


Final thoughts:
The descriptive model would be a good shielding wall to protect my argument from the refutation part of the normative model theory.

2014년 12월 4일 목요일

Final Draft - Do people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs?

     Humans reason every day and every time in their lives. People, more than often, do are not aware of their thinking whether it is processing subjectively or objectively. People often support the idea of first one, because in rapidly changing society of techniques, people should reason in sophisticated and accurate way. On the other hand, others argue that people are subjective in seeing themselves because they look themselves as the first person. I wondered whether people judge their behaviors or beliefs objectively or subjectively. People like to take some fun psychological tests for enjoying. However, that does not mean that they are fully interested in learning how their minds are doing and what are the results of their working. I want to raise their awareness about their mind and let them truly feel how their inner mind are operated, affecting their behaviors and beliefs. So, I made one question, 'Do people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs?' Justifying one's behavior and beliefs means that one person judges him or herself in a subjective way when one made some fault that includes minor things to cruel things. I agree with this topic. I believe that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs when they did something not acceptable or wrong. Before I give you more specific reasons to support my argument, I'll introduce more backgrounds about my topic to let you know what I'm going to persuade you.
     Since Socrates stated his opinion about humans, saying "Humans are reasonable, objective, and rational."(Socrates, 2007), people had begun to study about human minds to prove the rationality of humans. And as time goes, the studies of human minds in rationalism was developed by lots of philosophers. The study of human minds was done especially by Descartes who said "I think, so I exist."(Rene Descartes, 1596-1650) which means that we think and behave according to logical truth. And one century later, Kant also studied about human minds, concluding "People are rational enough to enact their kindhearted behaviors, and they always do so." (Kritik der reinen Vernunft, 1781). These three philosophers other than ancient, medieval, and current philosophers were also providing the evidences to let people know that they are reasonable in thinking and behaving. Despite their efforts to define humans as rational beings, lots of psychologists nowadays insist that humans are not rational, rather they try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cases of making mistakes. And objectiveness of humans is working every time in lives. For example, each of employers decides who will be new employees in their companies, and judges make their mind how long criminals would be in jail. Also, doctors talk to patients in objective views with coldness about how long they can maintain their lives, and experts prove mathematical proportions. However, people make mistakes in those accurate and objective works. And their minds begin to work as they didn’t do anything wrong, which means that people justified themselves. This fact proves that people are no more rational, especially in the views of themselves. And people are also barely aware of their inner working of justification in their behaviors and beliefs. Let’s take a specific example in reality. One child broke the window with his baseball, while he was playing in front of neighbor's yard. Right after the accident, he didn’t judge his fault of breaking the window with his rational thought, not saying 'I should go into the house and say sorry to the host, paying the whole cost of the window.' He said 'It was just a mistake. The host will generously forgive my fault. Wait! Wasn't it you who didn't catch my ball? Yeah, you should pay for the cost of the broken window! It's your fault.' or 'It was just a mistake. The host will understand this as a cute act of a young child. Then, let's run away!'(MW middle school, 2011) I used this example of the kid because this shows the situation that happens very often and common, especially in school or after school, and because I actually saw this kind of guy who was in the same middle school class with me.
     Therefore, as we live in reality, we should and need to think and know our real shape of minds. And we, human beings are not rational and even justify our behaviors and beliefs for ourselves. So, I'm on an affirmative side of the topic, arguing that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs. I'm going to provide two reasons to support my opinion. First, human minds control human bodies in thinking and behaving. Second, humans are selfish and are not perfect beings in thinking and behaving.
     Not to misunderstand our mind workings and not to treat our inner world with ignorance, we should know and learn about our self-justification working proved in the psychological field according to several results of experiments and studies(David A. Schroeder, 1995) (John DeLamater, 2006) (Leigh L. Thompson, 2003) (Wang, John, 2012) (Gregg Henriques, 2011).
     Perhaps one of the challenges is to understand human minds, working in the actual world. Let's first look at the human mind that controls human bodies(including behaviors). Because human minds are not rational rather, those are subjective which means that they are vulnerable to justify human behaviors and beliefs. According to the Placebo effect, the experiment showed that patients were able to recover their sicknesses though when they ate counterfeited medicines from doctors(Anne Harrington, 1999). This effect proves that the human are relying on personal thoughts and beliefs beneficial for themselves. If they are accurate and rational, they would not get better from the sicknesses, and rather they would maintain their sicknesses same as before the medicine taking as after the medicine taking. Also, there is a theory of cognitive dissonance(The Harvard Sampler, 2012). When conflicting ideas exist in one human brain, one person will delete one idea to support what he wants to think. For example, when a person smokes, he already knows about the badness of cigarettes. The idea that 'Smoking in not good for my health' and another idea that 'Smoking makes me get out of so many stresses' are conflicting. However, if he determined to smoke, he would ignore the first idea to justify his behaviors of smoking. In addition, according to Barnum, he made a theory of the Forer effect(Socially psyched, 2014). The experiments to show this effect was set in psychological tests of personal characters, and respondents took psychological tests of their own. They were all got results from the psychology experts, and they recorded that their results were almost same with what they are. However, unfortunately, all respondents got same result papers. This result shows that people tend to misjudge the situation occurred right to themselves, especially about their psychological results or something like that. Furthermore, in the Stanford Prison experiment, SPE, done by Philip George Zimbardo, experimenters set applied attendants into prisoners and police officers randomly(Knowing people, 2005). And both groups were promised to get money in the case of fulfilling certain days inside the prison. However, prisoners began to be more frightful, and police officers started to suppress prisoners cruelly and strangely. Those who played police role justified their bad behaviors toward another group of people because they thought that they were real police officers. This experiment shows that people are consciously or unconsciously subjectively fitting their positions to what they believe to be or should be which is corresponding to the word 'justifying'.
     Second, humans are selfish and are not perfect beings in thinking and behaving. Because they are selfish in thinking and behaving especially when the situation is occurred to them, people would justify their faults. According to Steven Pinker, who wrote the Harvard Sampler's psychology part, he said that humans are selfish, though they behave with reciprocity in the case of threat from others(The Harvard sampler, 2012). For example of 'Ultimatum game', humans divide money almost equally because they fear of a bad reputation if they divide the money unequally. However, in the experiment of 'Dictator game', humans who play a role to divide the money get lion's share to have the biggest benefits, which means that humans are selfish. So, when we use this example to the case of people who made some faults, they would certainly try to cover up the incidents(equal to justifying). In addition, according to self-serving bias, any cognitive or perceptual process will be distorted by the need to maintain and enhance self-esteem(감정독재(Korean book wrote by Jun-Man Kang), 2013). And by the working of this effect, people operate strong will to protect the ego from threat and injury even when they made some faults. This experiment proves that humans try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cases of making mistakes or faults. And in the story of Narcissism, the main character of an ancient story of Narcissus fell into the river and died because he love himself so much(Narcissism, 1993). People are thinking in self-egoistic ways like this kind of tale. So humans will do whatever to protect their beliefs toward themselves, even if it is justifying their behaviors or beliefs.
     Obviously, my opinion is not the recognized study, despite being correct one. There are some people who will dispute my position with examples of normative models, computation ability proved in ‘cognitive biological approach’, and powerful philosophers like Kant or Descartes. Of course, these arguments are all shortsighted and simply incorrect. First of all, normative models-have two types, deductive and inductive reasoning which recognize that humans have rationality-are an idealistic theory about how people do with certain things or situations(The Harvard Sampler, 2012). In other words, the study of normative models is the theory that proves how people ought to think and reason in idealistic ways, and how people should and must behave in a certain situation. While psychologists have studied that people ought to reason in a way of normative models, they figured that people behave far from the normative models. Instead, psychologists found that people behave in a way of descriptive models which show how people react in actual situations. Descriptive models are the theory that defines how people behave and deal with their situations in reality. And this showed that people sometimes reason in self-egoistic way. Because we live in reality, not in an idealistic world, we should focus on the second one which is the descriptive model saying what people are going to do when the actual occasion occurs to them. Next, computation ability recognized in cognitive biological approach means that human brains work like computer in computation(The Harvard Sampler, 2012). So, it supposes that people will apply the same rule in judging themselves, objective and accurate. However, the computational theory in the cognitive biological approach can be falsified by one of the evidences that I offered to support my opinion. The problem of opposition is that it's too idealistic to be accepted because all people are not a saint and might have experienced self-justification at least one time in their lives(감정독재(Korean book wrote by Jun Man Kang), 2013). For example, the placebo effect that patients get better with having counterfeited medicines is refuting the idea of human computational ability. So, the truth is that humans are subjective in looking themselves especially when they made some faults(The placebo effect, 1999). Lastly, philosophers like Kant or Descartes stated their opinions about humans defining that they are rational beings in reasoning and behaving so that they always do pure and right things or so that they always think in the way of scientific styles which include deductive reasoning(Kritik der reinen Vernunft, 1781)(Principle of philosophy, 1984). These people who believed humans are rational beings are just two of so many philosophers who ever had existed, studying human minds and philosophy. There were also those who supported human empiricism that means that people are subjective in reasoning and judging something else. People might sometimes reason in an objective way as opponents argue, but people not when the cases are applied to themselves. People are certainly subjective and generous to themselves, so that they try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cased of wrongdoing.
     It is hard to acknowledge that human minds become selfish when they commit the wrong things or faults. We are the owners of our lives. So, we should stop hiding behind our mind workings, and should directly see our psychological facts that we all try to justify our behaviors and beliefs. People use their ability of displaying rationality. People engage in the field of law such as judge and lawyer, and they are required to be objective in determining and judging others. Also, people have jobs of teachers and doctors, who should be rational and accurate. However, most of them do not use their rationality to themselves. I'm emphasizing you the truth in our real world. It's time to 'face to the present situation'. Human rationality is too idealistic to accept nowadays. And the increasing number of theories and proved evidences from lots of experiments are too reliable to refuse just because of the weak refutation from the opponents. Reminding our personal experiences, we can recognize ourselves justifying our faults just for ourselves in unconsciousness or consciousness. Even though Kant insisted human pure rationality saying 'Humans have innate pure rationality so that they would behave according to pure beliefs.'(Kritik der reinen Vernunft, 1781), people are consistently making faults. They make mistakes and justify them, make them and justify them, make them and justify them, etc. As we are not perfect existences, and as we reason in the first person, we make faults, and we have scopes to allow ourselves to justify our behaviors and beliefs. It's how we, human beings keep our images to be protected in the long run. And, it's how we, human beings maintain our lives. Therefore, for these reasons, my argument that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs is acceptable and should be accepted. So, from now on, admitting human subjectivity and abilities of self-justification is essential for us.

2014년 11월 16일 일요일

Week14 - Peer review 20224 최준환

     Everyone who lives in the earth and all of them may be interested in well-being and health. Also they may concern physical ability and physical activity everyday. Naturally, people are interested in how to enhance physical ability and how to have advanced result. Especially, in sport games, players have to enhance their physical ability and make better score. Then they have to do special things that can bring physical advance. There are many ways to improve better records, but I think concentration and calming down one's mind during physical activity can cause advanced score and enhanced physical ability the most. Before starting, you should know the definition of word, "concentration". Concentration on something involves giving all your attention to one thing. In other words, spend all of your concerns to it. Calming down one's mind is acting like control one's condition, state.
     Controlling one's mind or calming down one's mind can influence the results about sport games or physical activities. There is a experiment that prove that concentration can make advanced physical ability. According to STEMWiki Hyperlibrary's study, Concentration can bring advanced result rate. The same argument applies whether the reaction involves collision between two different particles or two of the same particle. In order for any reaction to happen, those particles must first collide. This is true whether both particles are in solution, or whether one is in solution and the other a solid. If the concentration is higher, the chances of collision are greater.
     Likewise, According to beverley high school, If you increase the concentration of the substrate in an enzyme controlled you will speed up the chemical reaction. The reason for this is as follows: The substrate and the enzyme need to come into contact with each other for a reaction to proceed. When the two meet they join for a brief moment while the reaction is catalysed, before separating. If there are very few substrate particles in the solution, it will take time for them to bump into an enzyme molecule and therefore the reaction will be slow.
     Also, An adequate level of physical activity may maintain or promote work ability. We can know that physical activity can bring better results when we make adequate level of physical activity by controlling one's mind or concentration. Actually according to my survey from 50 students, 42 of 05 students feel that their physical ability is advanced or have better records when they control their mind and concentrate more.
According to my case, when I play sports or do physical activities, I feel enhanced physical abilities and can have better scores when I calming down my mind and concentrate more than before in badminton, basketball, soccer. So I search more in physical activities not especially in sports. Then, results are same. In every physical activities, I can get better score when i concentrate more. Additionally, According to my research from 50 students, 42 students feel enhanced physical ability and can get better records when they calming down and concentrate more than before.
     From these we can know that controlling one's mind, condition and calming down one's mind during sport games or physical activity is very important things. That is because these behaviors can enhance physical ability and increase reaction rate, so they can get better scores. Also through these behaviors, they can control their mind stable.
     I think Opponents who don't agree with my thoughts may say that better result and concentration or calming down are not related, they are just coincidence. However that is not realistic, just suggests. As i mentioned before, concentration cause chemical reaction to enhance reaction rate more. This means that there are relations between concentration and advanced physical advance. Additionally, I think opponents will say that concentration is just one way of mental controlling and it is seemed that influence one's ability and results. However, I think concentration and calming down one's mind during sports game are the most important way to get better results. There are many ways but these are the most influential, powerful way.
     Until now, I mention about "Controlling and calming down one's mind during physical activity can cause advanced result". As i said, there are many evidences. Our body knows it, we know ourselves, result of research prove it. These are enough to prove this argument. Especially in physical activities, concentration and calming down one's mind have very important role. These are the most effective, powerful ways to make advanced results and enhanced physical ability. Already, many sports players know this and use in many matches. If you do these properly, you can get benefits from these in physical activities. Concentration and calming down one's mind is related with our brain, and control brain. So brain can control our body and make our physical abilities enhanced. These are not just coincidence. These are the results of body and brain's interaction. Thus, If you control or calm down your mind(escape from exited condition), you can cause advanced result and enhanced physical abilities.




Grade



According to the rubric above, what grade would you give this essay? Why?
This essay deserves a three. The perspective is fresh and I can understand.

How does this essay need to improve to get a better grade?
The essay topic is not apparently proposed on the top of his essay. I wondered what he will argue about and what's his own opinion until I read the last part of the essay. Though he suggested persuasive and full backgrounds and evidences to prove his opinion but I think it would better to put his resolution clearly in introduction like in the conclusion. And I also think that he needs to state his major supporting detail definitely, not flowing in the paragraphs.




Thesis


What is the thesis?
Controlling and calming down one's mind during physical activity can cause advanced result.

Is the thesis clear and debatable?
Little bit yes, because there are rebutting points and own supporting points, too.

If you (The reviewer) wrote this essay, how would you have written the thesis?
Controlling and calming down one's mind during physical activities can cause advanced results. I will write the essay in the same opinion with him

Any other thoughts?This is interesting. I could never come up with this kind of topic because it's hard to deal with in the argumentative essay, but the degree of completion of this essay is high.




Classical Argument


Can you easily identify the 5 parts of the classical argument? If no, what parts are missing?
I can see all parts of the classical argument. But I think that the narration part is little bit not enough to show the interesting backgrounds of the essay or the topic.

Does the introduction catch your attention? Does it comfortably lead to the thesis? Yes. The introduction is what almost all of people might consider in their daily lives.

Does the narration give all the necessary background information to understand the topic?
Yes, but it is missing conjecture about the future. Just because current technology doesn't beat brain power, there is no reason to believe it won't eventually be able to.

Does the confirmation adequately support the thesis?
Yes. The writer used adequate researches and supported his opinion with reliable studies or results or opinions.

Does the refutation and concession address a realistic counterpoint? Does it adequately dispute the counterpoint, or respond in a reasonable manner?

I don't think so. I think the refutation part is little bit weak and little bit not strong or easy to answer in the perspective of the writer.

Does the conclusion summarize the article and address the larger significance of the thesis? 
Yes. He suggested various consequences of how it will happen if the readers support his opinion, exercise.

What suggestions do you have for improving the classical argument structure?
The narration is inadequate. Develop it - Tell us about those who agree with you and disagree with you.





Persuasion


When you started reading the essay, did you agree or disagree with the thesis? I agreed with the thesis.

When you finished the essay, did you agree or disagree with the thesis?
I still agreed with the thesis.

If your mind changed, why? What parts of the essay were persuasive?
I did not change my mind.

How could the author enhance the persuasive parts of their essay?
Consider more possible rebutting points from opposite sides.





Research


Is the author using research effectively? Yes. The author is using research effectively.

Is the research from appropriate sources?
Yes. The research is from appropriate sources.

Are the sources obvious?
Yes, the sources are obvious.

Are the pieces of evidence relevant to the thesis or essay?
Yes. The pieces of evidence relevant to the thesis or essay.

Are there any parts of the essay that need evidence to support the claims?No. That's enough to support the opinion.

2014년 11월 14일 금요일

Week12 - Research

My thesis:

People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


Source:

http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/descriptive-model.html


What I hope to learn from this source:

I want to learn about descriptive model which will used to shield my argument from the attack of normative model theory.


Notes:

The descriptive model is how people actually do.


Final thoughts:

The descriptive model would be a good shielding wall to protect my argument from the refutation part of the normative model theory.


ADD+

My thesis:

People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.



Source : 

감정 독재 - 강준만(Jun-Man Kang)





What I hope to learn from this source:

I want to learn about self-serving bias that affects human life.



Notes:

People have their own self-serving biases and they think in egoistic way especially when they are in unfavorable situation or occupation.



Final thoughts:

I can use this idea in my main points to argue that humans reason depending on self-serving bias. Therefore, people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs, especially when the situation is disadvantageous to themselves.

Week12 - Research

My thesis:

People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


Source:

http://toolkit.smallbiz.nsw.gov.au/part/8/42/200


What I hope to learn from this source:

I want to gain some opposite opinions to used them in my refutation part of my essay.


Note:

Normative model defines that people are rational.
So, people prefer the situations that require less efforts to deal with and choose them which are "good enough".


Models of Decision-making

Final thoughts:

I think this normative model theory is good at refuting my argument but I can find some weak points of this theory. So it will be better for me to use this kind of theory in my refutation part of my essay.

2014년 11월 9일 일요일

Second Draft - Do people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs?

     Humans reason every day and every time in their lives. Then, do they reason in objective ways or subjective ways in the case of judging themselves? People often support the idea of first one, because in rapidly changing society of techniques, people should reason in sophisticated and accurate way, no matter the judgement of themselves like a mirror. On the other hand, others argue that people are subjective in seeing themselves because they look themselves as the first person. I wondered whether people judge their behaviors or beliefs objectively or subjectively. People like to take some fun psychological tests for enjoying. However, that does not mean that they are fully interested in learning how their minds are doing and what are the results of their working. I wanted to wake them up from ignorance of their minds, and make them understand their inner operation, affecting their behaviors and beliefs. So, I made one question, 'Do people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs?' Justifying one's behavior and beliefs means that one person judges him or herself in a subjective way when one made some fault that includes minor things to cruel things. And I stated my opinion to agree with the topic. I believe that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs when they did something not acceptable or wrong. Before I give you more specific reasons to support my argument, I'll introduce more backgrounds about my topic to let you know what I'm going to persuade you.
 
     Since Socrates stated his opinion about humans, saying "Humans are reasonable, objective, and rational.", people had begun to study about human minds to prove the rationality of humans. And as time goes, the studies of human minds in rationalism was developed by lots of philosophers. The study of human minds was done especially by Descartes who said "I think, so I exist." which means that we think and behave according to logical truth. And one century later, Kant also studied about human minds, concluding "People are rational enough to enact their kindhearted behaviors, and they always do so." These three philosophers other than ancient, medieval, and current philosophers were also providing the evidences to let people know that they are reasonable in thinking and behaving. Despite their efforts to define humans as rational beings, lots of psychologists nowadays insist that humans are not rational, rather they try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cases of making mistakes. And objectiveness of humans is working every time in lives. For example, each of employers decides who will be new employees in their companies, and judges make their mind how long criminals would be in jail. Also, doctors talk to patients in objective views with coldness about how long they can maintain their lives, and experts prove mathematical proportions. However, people make mistakes in those accurate and objective works. And their minds begin to work as they didn’t do anything wrong, which means that people justified themselves. This fact proves that people are no more rational, especially in the views of themselves. And people are also barely aware of their inner working of justification in their behaviors and beliefs. Let’s take a specific example in reality. One child broke the window with his baseball, while he was playing in front of neighbor's yard. Right after the accident, he didn’t judge his fault of breaking the window with his rational thought, not saying 'I should go into the house and say sorry to the host, paying the whole cost of the window.' He said 'It was just a mistake. The host will generously forgive my fault. Wait! Wasn't it you who didn't catch my ball? Yeah, you should pay for the cost of the broken window! It's your fault.' or 'It was just a mistake. The host will understand this as a cute act of a young child. Then, let's run away!'
 
     Therefore, as we live in reality, we should and need to think and know our real shape of minds. And we, human beings are not rational and even justify our behaviors and beliefs for ourselves. So, I'm on an affirmative side of the topic that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs. I'm going to provide two reasons to support my opinion. First, human minds control human bodies in thinking and behaving. Second, humans are selfish and are not perfect beings in thinking and behaving.
 
     Not to misunderstand our mind workings and not to treat our inner world with ignorance, we should know and learn about our self-justification working proved in the psychological field according to several results of experiments and studies.
 
     Perhaps one of the challenges is to understand human minds, working in the actual world. Let's first look at the human mind that controls human bodies(including behaviors). Because human minds are not rational rather, those are subjective which means that they are vulnerable to justify human behaviors and beliefs. According to the Placebo effect, the experiment showed that patients were able to recover their sicknesses though when they ate counterfeited medicines from doctors. This proves that human are relying on personal thoughts and beliefs beneficial for themselves. If they are accurate and rational, they would actually not get better from the sicknesses, rather they would maintain their sicknesses same as before the medicine taking as after the medicine taking. Also, there is a theory of cognitive dissonance. When conflicting ideas exist in one human brain, one person will delete one idea to support what he wants to think. For example, when a person smokes, he already knows about the badness of cigarettes. The idea that 'Smoking in not good for my health' and another idea that 'Smoking makes me get out of so many stresses' are conflicting. However, if he determined to smoke, he would ignore the first idea to justify his behaviors of smoking. In addition, according to Barnum, he made a theory of the Forer effect. The experiments to show this effect was set in psychological tests of personal characters, and respondents took psychological tests of their own. They were all got results from the psychology experts, and they recorded that their results were almost same with what they are. However, unfortunately, all respondents got same result papers. This result shows that people tend to misjudge the situation occurred right to themselves, especially about their psychological results or something like that. Furthermore, in the Stanford Prison experiment, SPE, done by Philip George Zimbardo, experimenters set applied attendants into prisoners and police officers randomly. And both groups were promised to get money in the case of fulfilling certain days inside the prison. However, prisoners began to be more frightful, and police officers started to suppress prisoners cruelly and strangely. Those who played police role justified their bad behaviors toward another group of people because they thought that they were real police officers. This experiment shows that people are consciously or unconsciously subjectively fitting their positions to what they believe to be or should be which is corresponding to the word 'justifying'.
 
     Second, humans are selfish and are not perfect beings in thinking and behaving. Because they are selfish in thinking and behaving especially when the situation is occurred to them, people would justify their faults. According to Steven Pinker, who wrote the Harvard Sampler's psychology part, he said that humans are selfish, though they behave with reciprocity in the case of threat from others. For example of 'Ultimatum game', humans divide money almost equally because they fear of a bad reputation if they divide the money unequally. However, in the experiment of 'Dictator game', humans who play a role to divide the money get lion's share to have the biggest benefits, which means that humans are selfish. So, when we use this example to the case of people who made some faults, they would certainly try to cover up the incidents(equal to justifying). In addition, according to self-serving bias, any cognitive or perceptual process will be distorted by the need to maintain and enhance self-esteem. And by the working of this effect, people operate strong will to protect the ego from threat and injury even when they made some faults. This experiment proves that humans try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cases of making mistakes or faults. Have you ever heard of Narcissism? The main character of an ancient story of Narcissus fell into the river and died, because he love himself so much. People are thinking in self-egoistic ways like this kind of tale. So humans will do whatever to protect their beliefs toward themselves, even if it is justifying their behaviors or beliefs.
 
     Obviously, my opinion is not the recognized study, despite being correct one. There are some people who will dispute my position with examples of normative models, computation ability proved in ‘cognitive biological approach’, and powerful philosophers like Kant or Descartes. Of course, these arguments are all shortsighted and simply incorrect. First of all, normative models-have two types, deductive and inductive reasoning which recognize that humans have rationality-are idealistical theory about how people do with certain things or situations. In other words, the study of normative models is the theory that proves how people ought to think and reason in idealistic ways, and how people should and must behave in a certain situation. While psychologists have studied that people ought to reason in a way of normative models, they figured that people behave depart from the normative models. Instead, psychologists found that people behave in a way of descriptive models which show how people react in actual situations. Descriptive models are the theory that defines how people behave and deal with their situations in reality. And this showed that people reason in self-egoistic way. Because we live in reality, not in an idealistic world, we should focus on the second one which is the descriptive model saying what people are going to do when the actual occasion occurs to them. Next, computation ability recognized in cognitive biological approach means that human brains work like computer in computation. So, it supposes that people will apply the same rule in judging themselves, objective and accurate. However, the computational theory in the cognitive biological approach can be falsified by one of evidences which I offered to support my opinion. The problem of opposition is that it's too idealistic to be accepted because all people are not a saint and might have experienced self-justification at least one time in their lives. For example, the placebo effect that patients get better with having counterfeited medicines is refuting the idea of human computational ability. So, the truth is that humans are subjective in looking themselves especially when they made some faults. Lastly, philosophers like Kant or Descartes stated their opinions about humans defining that they are rational beings in reasoning and behaving so that they always do pure and right things or so that they always think in the way of scientific styles which include deductive reasoning. These people who believed humans are rational beings are just two of so many philosophers who ever had existed, studying human minds and philosophy. There were also those who supported human empiricism that means that people are subjective in reasoning and judging something else. People might sometimes reason in an objective way as opponents argue, but people not when the cases are applied to themselves. People are certainly subjective and generous to themselves, so that they try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cased of wrongdoing.
 
     It is hard to acknowledge that human minds become selfish when they commit the wrong things or faults. We are the owners of our lives. So, we should stop hiding behind our mind workings, and should directly see our psychological facts that we all try to justify our behaviors and beliefs. People use their ability of displaying rationality. People engage in the field of law such as judge and lawyer, and they are required to be objective in determining and judging others. Also, people have jobs of teachers and doctors, who should be rational and accurate. However, most of them do not use their rationality to themselves. I'm emphasizing you the truth in our real world. It's time to 'face to the present situation'. Human rationality is too idealistic to accept nowadays. And the increasing number of theories and proved evidences from lots of experiments are too reliable to refuse just because of weak refutation from the opponents. Reminding our personal experiences, we can recognize ourselves justifying our faults just for ourselves in unconsciousness or consciousness. Even though Kant insisted human pure rationality saying 'Humans have innate pure rationality so that they would behave according to pure beliefs.', people are consistently making faults. They make them and justify them, make them and justify them, make them and justify them, and etc. As we are not perfect existences, and as we reason in the first person, we make faults, and we have scopes to allow ourselves to justify our behaviors and beliefs. It's how we, human beings keep our images to be protected in the long run. And, it's how we, human beings maintain our lives. Therefore, for these reasons, my argument that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs is acceptable and should be acceptable. So, from now on, admitting human subjectivity and abilities of self-justification is essential for us.

2014년 10월 26일 일요일

Week11 - Self evaluation



First, what score do you think you deserve? Write a brief justification. Think about it, then look at my answer.

- I think I deserve 1 point. I have all 5 parts of classical argument, but my essay is not that much well-organized, and not that strong to persuade someone. And I understand how to write classical argument.




Next, let's decide what did you do well, and what could you do better? Think about it, then look at my answers.


1) I have good researches to support my opinion, I think. The researches are all related to my topic, and they are capable of easy understanding.

2) I could do better in organizing my argumentative essay. And I also could do better my narration part, because it's not fully explaining of my topic purposes





Please recall the 5 parts of the classical argument. Which part of the classical argument did you use the best? Which part could be improved? Think about it, then look at my answers.

1) My best part of the classical argument is confirmation part, because I logically wrote my opinion based on reliable researches.


2) My worst part of the classical argument is narration part, because I didn't explain full background of my topic and didn't show my topic logically.







Last, what's your strategy for your next draft? Where will you focus your attention to make the second draft stronger?

- I will focus on improving my narration part to let readers know full background of my topic and how I will set my argumentative essay based on what and why I think it's appropriate, and also how my topic would affect the world if I'm right.

2014년 10월 25일 토요일

First Draft - Do people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs?

     Humans reason everyday, every time in their lives. Then, do they reason in objective ways or subjective ways in the case of judging themselves? People often support the idea of first one, because in rapidly changing society of techniques, people should reason in sophisticated and accurate way, no matter the judgement of themselves like a mirror. On the other hand, others argue that people are subjective in seeing themselves because they look themselves as the first person. I wondered whether people judge their behaviors or beliefs objectively or subjectively. People like to take some fun psychological tests for enjoying. However, that does not mean that they are fully interested in learning how their minds are doing and what are the results of their working. I wanted to wake them up from ignorance of their minds, and make them understand their inner operation affecting their behaviors and beliefs. So, I made one question, 'Do people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs?' Justifying one's behavior and beliefs means that one person judges him or herself in subjective way when one made some fault which includes minor things to cruel things. And I stated my opinion to agree with the topic. I believe that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs when they did something not acceptable or wrong. Before I give you more specific reasons to support my argument, I'll introduce more backgrounds about my topic to let you know what I'm going to persuade you.
Since Socrates stated his opinion about humans, saying that "Humans are reasonable, objective, and rational.", people had begun to study about human minds to prove the rationality of humans. And as time goes, the studies of humans mind in rationalism was developed by lots of philosophers. This was done especially by Descartes who said that "I think, so I exist." which means that we think and behave according to our intuitive logical truth. And one century later, Kant also studied about human minds, concluding that "People are rational enough to enact their kindhearted behaviors, and they always do so." These three philosophers other than ancient, medieval, and current philosophers were also providing the evidences to let people know that they are reasonable in thinking and behaving. Despite their efforts to define humans as rational beings, lots of psychologists nowadays insist that humans are not rational, rather they try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cases of making mistakes. And objectiveness of humans are working everytime in lives. For example, employers choose appliers about who would be their new employees in every normal companies, and judges make their mind how long criminals would be in jail. Also, doctors talk to patients in objective views with coldness about how long they are able to live their lives, and experts prove mathematical proportions. However, people make mistakes in those accurate and objective works. And their minds begin to work as they didn't anything wrong, which means that people justified themselves. This fact proves that people are no more rational in the views of themselves. And people are also barely aware of their inner working of justification in their behaviors and beliefs.
For example, one person broke the window with his baseball, when he was playing in front of neighbor's yard. Right after the accident, he might never judge the broken window with his rational thought, like 'I should go into the house and say sorry to the host, paying the whole cost of the window.' We often think that 'It was just a mistake. The host will generously forgive my fault. Wait! Wasn't it you who didn't catch my ball? Yeah, you should pay for the cost of the broken window! It's your fault.' or 'It was just a mistake. The host will understand this as a cute act of children. Then, let's run away!'
Therefore, as we live in reality, we need to and should think and know our real shape of minds. And in reality, we, human beings are not rational and even justify our behaviors and beliefs for ourselves. So, I'm on an affirmative side of the topic that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs. I'm going to provide two reasons to support my opinion. First, human minds control human bodies in thinking and behaving. Second, humans are selfish and are not perfect beings in thinking and behaving.
Not to misunderstand our mind workings and not to treat our inner world with ignorance, we should know and learn about our self-justification working proved in psychological field according to several results of experiments and studies.
Perhaps one of the challenges is to understand human minds, working in actual world. Let's first look at the human mind that controls human bodies(including behaviors). Because human minds are not rational rather those are subjective which means that they are vulnerable to justify human behaviors and beliefs. According to the Placebo effect, the experiment showed that patients were able to recover their sicknesses though when they ate counterfeited medicines from doctors. This proves that human are relying on personal thoughts and beliefs beneficial for themselves, because if they are accurate and rational, they would actually not get better from the sicknesses, rather they would maintain their sicknesses samely as before the medicine taking as after the medicine taking. Also, there is a theory of cognitive dissonance. When conflicting ideas are existing in one human brain, one person would delete one idea to support what he wants to think. For example, when a person smokes, he already knows about the badness of cigarettes. The idea that 'Smoking in not good for my health' and another idea that 'Smoking makes me get out of so many stress' are conflicting. However, if he determined to smoke, he would ignore the first idea to justify his behaviors of smoking. In addition, according to Barnum, he made a theory of the Forer effect. The experiments to show this effect was set in psychological tests of personal characters, and respondents took psychological tests of their own. They were all got results from the psychology experts, and they recorded that their results are almost same with what really they are. However, unfortunately, all respondents got same result papers. This shows that people tend to misjudge the situation occurred right to themselves, especially about their own psychological results or something like that. Furthermore, in the Stanford Prison experiment, SPE, done by Philip George Zimbardo, experimenters set applied attendants into prisoners and polices randomly. And both groups were promised to get money in the case of fulfilling certain days inside the prison. However prisoners began to be more frightful, and polices started to suppress prisoners cruelly and strangely. Those who played police role justified their bad behaviors toward other group of people because they thought that they are really polices. This shows that people are consciously or unconsciously subjectively fitting their positions to what they believe to be or should be which is corresponsive to the word 'justifying'.
Second, humans are selfish and are not perfect beings in thinking and behaving. Because they are selfish in thinking and behaving especially when the situation is occurred to them, people would really justify their faults. According to Steven Pinker who wrote the Harvard Sampler's psychology part, he said that humans are actually selfish though they behave with reciprocity in the case of threat from others. For example of 'Ultimatum game', humans divide money almost equally because they fear of bad reputation if they divide money unequally. However, in 'Dictator game', humans who play a role to divide money get lion's share to have the biggest benefits, which means that humans are selfish. So, when we use this example to the case of people who made some faults, they would certainly try to cover up the incidents(equal to justifying). In addition, according to self-serving bias, any cognitive or perceptual process will be distorted by the need to maintain and enhance self-esteem. And by the working of this effect, people operate strong will to protect the ego from threat and injury even when they made some faults. This proves that humans try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cases of making mistakes or faults. Have you ever heard of Narcissism? This is the story of Narcissus who went into the river and died because he love himself so much. People are thinking in self-egoistic ways like this kind of tale. So humans will do whatever to protect their beliefs toward themselves, even if it is justifying their behaviors or beliefs.
Obviously, my opinion is not the recognized study, despite being correct one. There are some people who will dispute my position with examples of normative models, computation ability in cognitive biological approach, and philosophers like Kant and Descartes. Of course, these arguments are all shortsighted and simply incorrect. First of all, normative models-have two types, deductive and inductive reasoning which recognize that humans have rationality-are not enacted by people in reality. While psychologists have studied that people ought to reason in a way of normative models, they also figured that people in real occasion behave depart from the normative models, rather they behave in a way of descriptive models which show how people react in actual situations. And this showed that people reason in self-egoistic way. Because we live in reality, not in idealistic world, we should focus on the second one which is descriptive model saying what people gonna do when the actual occasion occurs to them. Next, computation ability recognized in cognitive biological approach-means that humans' brains work like computer in computation, so it supposes that people will apply the same rule in judging themselves, objective and accurate-can be falsified by one of evidences which I offered to support my opinion. The problem of opposition is that it's too idealistic to be accepted, because all people are not a saint and might have experienced self-justification at least one time in their lives. For example, the placebo effect that patients get better with having counterfeited medicines is refuting the idea of human computational ability. So, the truth is that humans are subjective in looking themselves especially when they made some faults. Lastly, philosophers like Kant or Descartes-stated their opinions about humans defining that they are rational beings in reasoning and behaving, so that they always do pure and right things or so that they always think in the way of scientific styles which include deductive reasoning-are just two of so many philosophers who ever had existed studying humans minds and philosophy. There were also those who supported human empiricism which means that people are subjective in reasoning and judging something else. People might sometimes reason in objective way as opponents argue, but people not when the cases are applied to themselves. People are definitely subjective and generous to themselves, so that they try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cased of wrongdoing.
It is hard to acknowledge that human minds become selfish when they commit the wrong things or faults. We are the owners of our lives. So, we should stop hiding behind our mind workings, and should directly see our psychological facts that we all try to justify our behaviors and beliefs. People use their ability of displaying rationality. People engages in the field of law such as judge and lawyer, and they are required to be objective in determining and judging others. Also, people have jobs of teachers and doctors, who should be rational and accurate. However, most of them do not use their rationality to themselves. I'm emphasizing you the truth in our real world. It's time to 'face to the present situation.' Human rationality is too idealistic to accept nowadays, and increasing theories and proved evidences from lots of experiments are too reliable to refuse just because of weak refutation from the opponents. Reminding our personal experiences, we are able to recognize ourselves justifying our faults just for ourselves in unconsciousness or in consciousness. Even though Kant insisted human pure rationality saying 'Humans have innate pure rationality so that they would behave according to pure beliefs.', people are consistently making faults. They make them and justify them, make them and justify them, make them and justify them, and on and on and on. As we are not perfect existences, and as we reason in the first person, we make faults and we have scopes to allow ourselves to justify our behaviors and beliefs. It's how we, human beings keep our images to be protected in the long run. And, it's how we, human beings maintain our lives. Therefore, for these reasons, my argument that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs is acceptable and should be acceptable. So, from now on, admitting human subjectivity and abilities of self-justification is essential for us.


Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissism
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-serving_bias
The Harvard Sampler (book) - Psychology part by Steven Pinker
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forer_effect
Opening Skinner's Box(스키너의 심리상자 열기) - Lauren Slater
http://www.sparknotes.com/philosophy/descartes/themes.html
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rationalism-empiricism/
http://psychology.about.com/od/pindex/f/placebo-effect.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-justification

http://breakingmuscle.com/sports-psychology/escalation-commitment-how-we-justify-bad-behavior

Week8 - Research

Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissism

My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.

What I hope to learn from this source:
I hope to know the story of Narcissus to prove that humans think in the way of protecting selves.

Notes:
1. Narcissus fell into the river and died because he loved himself so much.
2. From this story, people would be able to infer the human self-justification effect and be able to know people will do so to protect themselves from getting hurt with the results of their faults.

Final thoughts:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs according to the effect of Narcissism.








+Research


Source:
The Harvard Sampler



My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.

What I hope to learn from this source:
I hope to learn about psychological theories that would refute my argument.

Notes:
1.Normative models are the theory of what people should do, such as deductive or inductive reasoning. However this is totally different from my opinion. Deductive and inductive reasoning is somewhat saying that humans are rational beings and deduce accurately.
2.Computation in cognitive biological approach is theory of how humans work like robots in managing works. I see this operation as human accuracy so that this supports the opposing idea to my opinion.

Final thoughts:
I can use normative models and computation in cognitive biological approach in my refutation part of essay.

Week8 - Research

Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-serving_bias

My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.

What I hope to learn from this source:
I hope to know about human selfishness to support my second argumentative essay reason.

Notes:
1. A self-serving bias is any cognitive or perceptual process that is distorted by the need to maintain and enhance self esteem. When individuals reject the validity of negative feedback, focus on their strengths and achievements but overlook their faults and failures, or take more responsibility for their group's work than they give to other members, they are protecting the ego from threat and injury. These cognitive and perceptual tendencies perpetuate illusions and error, but they also serve the self's need for esteem.
I can use this theory in my second reason appropriately to support the idea of human selfishness.

Final thoughts:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs to protect themselves according to the theory of self-serving bias.

Week8 - Research

Source:
The Harvard Sampler (book) - Psychology part by Steven Pinker



My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.

What I hope to learn from this source:
I hope to find evidences to prove that humans are actually selfish beings.

Notes:
1. The author mentioned 'Ultimatum game' and 'Dictator game'. Ultimatum game shows that humans are sensitive to the responds of other humans and to the reputation which humans would tell to somebody else. This looks like odd, because humans are actually selfish. So he also cited dictator game to show how humans behave without threat from others.
2. This theory exactly shows that human innate minds are actually selfish and they try to get the best advantage in certain cases. So I think I can apply this effect to my topic, saying that humans are so selfish so they would try to justify their behaviors and beliefs when they are in disadvantaged situation like making faults.

Final thoughts:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs according to ultimatum and dictator game.

Week8 - Research

Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment

My thesis:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.

What I hope to learn from this source:
I want to learn about human mind in extreme occasion, and about self-reflection of themselves.

Notes:
1. Experts set tests in the condition of prison, real prison. They divided attendants to two groups randomly; one is criminals, and the other is polices. Both were promised to get money when they endure the certain days in prison. In the beginning, both got along well with each other. However, polices started to suppress criminals and so criminals started to be cruel toward polices. Both began to think in the way of what they were selected to: polices or criminals. Eventually, their fought was getting bigger, and this led them to kill each other.
2. I think that this experiment shows that humans justify their positions and behaviors toward others in certain cases.

Final thoughts:
People try to justify their behaviors according to Stanford prison experiment.

Week8 - Research

Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forer_effect

My topic:
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.

What I hope to learn from this source:
I hope to learn about Forer effect (also it is called Barnum effect) that was known to support my thesis.

Notes:
1. psychologist Barnum gathered some experimenters. And experimenters got tests which let them know about their personal characters. Then, the result papers were came out and most attenders recorded that those results are really as same as what they thing they are. However, in fact, all respondents got same result papers. This does not mean that all humans have same personal characters. This means that humans strongly believe the experts' saying and so they justified the results, formative characters to fit with their own characters.
2. I think that this experiment is appropriate to use in my essay, because this proves that humans are not objective rather they are so subjective so that they justify their beliefs, making the results of experts' tests fit with their own ones.

Final thoughts:
People try to justify their beliefs according to Forer(Barnum) effect.

Week8 - Research

<Opening Skinner's Box(스키너의 심리상자 열기) - Lauren Slater>





This book is 'Opening Skinner's Box'.

I read the book before I began to write my argumentative essay, but I could learned lots of psychological experiments from this book.

So, I employed several theories and proved tests to cite on my essay writing.

I post this lecture to let you know why my researches are directly associated with my topic and why I searched only more specific information about some of psychological experiments or effects.

I already got some nice information from this book so I did not wrote from where I got to know some kinds of psychological experiments.

ex) cognitive dissonance

2014년 10월 24일 금요일

Week7 - Research

My topic :

People try to justify their beliefs and behaviors.
(Human minds are able to control our beliefs and behaviors.)


http://www.sparknotes.com/philosophy/descartes/themes.html

What I hope to learn from this source : 

I wanted to learn about philosopher Descartes to know his ideas toward human beings.


Notes : 

1. Descartes believed that human reasons like science.
2. Descartes claimed that rationalism is prior to empiricism.


Final thoughts : 

I should quote his words in search of humans beings, because they are conflicting with my opinion.

Week10 - Conclusion

My Conclusion:

It is hard to acknowledge that human minds become selfish when they commit the wrong things or faults. We are the owners of our lives. So, we should stop hiding behind our mind workings, and should directly see our psychological facts that we all try to justify our behaviors and beliefs. People use their ability of displaying rationality. People engages in the field of law such as judge and lawyer, and they are required to be objective in determining and judging others. Also, people have jobs of teachers and doctors, who should be rational and accurate. However, most of them do not use their rationality to themselves. I'm emphasizing you the truth in our real world. It's time to 'face to the present situation.' Human rationality is too idealistic to accept nowadays, and increasing theories and proved evidences from lots of experiments are too reliable to refuse just because of weak refutation from the opponents. Reminding our personal experiences, we are able to recognize ourselves justifying our faults just for ourselves in unconsciousness or in consciousness. Even though Kant insisted human pure rationality saying 'Humans have innate pure rationality so that they would behave according to pure beliefs.', people are consistently making faults. They make them and justify them, make them and justify them, make them and justify them, and on and on and on. As we are not perfect existences, and as we reason in the first person, we make faults and we have scopes to allow ourselves to justify our behaviors and beliefs. It's how we, human beings keep our images to be protected in the long run. And, it's how we, human beings maintain our lives. Therefore, for these reasons, my argument that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs is acceptable and should be acceptable. So, from now on, admitting human subjectivity and abilities of self-justification is essential for us.

Week9 - Refutation and Confession

My Refutation and Confession:

Obviously, my opinion is not the recognized study, despite being correct one. There are some people who will dispute my position with examples of normative models, computation ability in cognitive biological approach, and philosophers like Kant and Descartes. Of course, these arguments are all shortsighted and simply incorrect. First of all, normative models-have two types, deductive and inductive reasoning which recognize that humans have rationality-are not enacted by people in reality. While psychologists have studied that people ought to reason in a way of normative models, they also figured that people in real occasion behave depart from the normative models, rather they behave in a way of descriptive models which show how people react in actual situations. And this showed that people reason in self-egoistic way. Because we live in reality, not in idealistic world, we should focus on the second one which is descriptive model saying what people gonna do when the actual occasion occurs to them. Next, computation ability recognized in cognitive biological approach-means that humans' brains work like computer in computation, so it supposes that people will apply the same rule in judging themselves, objective and accurate-can be falsified by one of evidences which I offered to support my opinion. The problem of opposition is that it's too idealistic to be accepted, because all people are not a saint and might have experienced self-justification at least one time in their lives. For example, the placebo effect that patients get better with having counterfeited medicines is refuting the idea of human computational ability. So, the truth is that humans are subjective in looking themselves especially when they made some faults. Lastly, philosophers like Kant or Descartes-stated their opinions about humans defining that they are rational beings in reasoning and behaving, so that they always do pure and right things or so that they always think in the way of scientific styles which include deductive reasoning-are just two of so many philosophers who ever had existed studying humans minds and philosophy. There were also those who supported human empiricism which means that people are subjective in reasoning and judging something else. People might sometimes reason in objective way as opponents argue, but people not when the cases are applied to themselves. People are definitely subjective and generous to themselves, so that they try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cased of wrongdoing.

Week9 - Refutation and Confession Qs

1. What is my thesis?
People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs .
 
2. What is the opposite position?
People are rational being so that they judge themselves objectively, not justifying themselves.
 
3. What arguments can I anticipate?
a) Normative models (People reason logically.)
b) Kant and Descartes (They are philosophers who insisted humans' rationality, opposing empiricism.)
c) Cognitive biological approach (This study shows that human minds are too complex to make mistakes and are computative in thinking.)
 
4. How will I counter those arguments?
a) Normative models are just study of what people ought to reason. Instead, the study of descriptive models is what people reason in reality, which means that descriptive models are far more important than normative models, because they are applicable right to humans.
b) They are just one of philosophers who insisted rationality of humans, and there are also many philosophers who supported my thesis.
c) This cannot explain why we excuse our faults.

Week8 - Confirmation

My Confirmation:

 
Perhaps one of the challenges is to understand human minds, working in actual world. Let's first look at the human mind that controls human bodies(including behaviors). Because human minds are not rational rather those are subjective which means that they are vulnerable to justify human behaviors and beliefs. According to the Placebo effect, the experiment showed that patients were able to recover their sicknesses though when they ate counterfeited medicines from doctors. This proves that human are relying on personal thoughts and beliefs beneficial for themselves, because if they are accurate and rational, they would actually not get better from the sicknesses, rather they would maintain their sicknesses same as before the medicine taking as after the medicine taking. Also, there is a theory of cognitive dissonance. When conflicting ideas are existing in one human brain, one person would delete one idea to support what he wants to think. For example, when a person smokes, he already knows about the badness of cigarettes. The idea that 'Smoking in not good for my health' and another idea that 'Smoking makes me get out of so many stress' are conflicting. However, if he determined to smoke, he would ignore the first idea to justify his behaviors of smoking. In addition, according to Barnum, he made a theory of the Forer effect. The experiments to show this effect was set in psychological tests of personal characters, and respondents took psychological tests of their own. They were all got results from the psychology experts, and they recorded that their results are almost same with what really they are. However, unfortunately, all responders got same result papers. This shows that people tend to misjudge the situation occurred right to themselves, especially about their own psychological results or something like that. Furthermore, in the Stanford Prison experiment, SPE, done by Philip George Zimbardo, experimenters set applied attendants into prisoners and polices randomly. And both groups were promised to get money in the case of fulfilling certain days inside the prison. However prisoners began to be more frightful, and polices started to suppress prisoners cruelly and strangely. Those who played police role justified their bad behaviors toward other group of people because they thought that they are really polices. This shows that people are consciously or unconsciously subjectively fitting their positions to what they believe to be or should be which is corresponsive to the word 'justifying'.