2014년 9월 28일 일요일

Week8 - Research

Source :

http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rationalism-empiricism/


My topic :

People try to justify their beliefs and behaviors.
(Human minds are able to control our beliefs and behaviors.)


What I hope to learn from this source : 

I wanted to learn about the origins of two different arguments about human minds which are called rationalism and empiricism. These are the beginning of my argumentative essay, because they represents main ideas about my topic's two opposite claims.


Notes : 

1. empiricism included intuition.
2. Descartes claimed that rationalism is prior to empiricism.


Final thoughts : 

I should search philosopher Descartes to examine the truth and probability of his thoughts, because they are conflicting with my opinion.

Week7 - Narration

My narration :


Since Socrates stated his opinion about humans, saying that "Humans are reasonable, objective, and rational.", people had begun to study about human minds to prove the rationality of humans. And as time goes, the studies of humans mind in rationalism was developed by lots of philosophers. This was done especially by Descartes who said that "I think, so I exist." which means that we think and behave according to our intuitive logical truth. And one century later, Kant also studied about human minds, concluding that "People are rational enough to enact their kindhearted behaviors, and they always do so." These three philosophers other than ancient, medieval, and current philosophers were also providing the evidences to let people know that they are reasonable in thinking and behaving. Despite their efforts to define humans as rational beings, lots of psychologists nowadays insist that humans are not rational, rather they try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the cases of making mistakes. And objectiveness of humans are working everytime in lives. For example, employers choose appliers about who would be their new employees in every normal companies, and judges make their mind how long criminals would be in jail. Also, doctors talk to patients in objective views with coldness about how long they are able to live their lives, and experts prove mathematical proportions. However, people make mistakes in those accurate and objective works. And their minds begin to work as they didn't anything wrong, which means that people justified themselves. This fact proves that people are no more rational in the views of themselves. And people are also barely aware of their inner working of justification in their behaviors and beliefs.
For example, one person broke the window with his baseball, when he was playing in front of neighbor's yard. Right after the accident, he might never judge the broken window with his rational thought, like 'I should go into the house and say sorry to the host, paying the whole cost of the window.' We often think that 'It was just a mistake. The host will generously forgive my fault. Wait! Wasn't it you who didn't catch my ball? Yeah, you should pay for the cost of the broken window! It's your fault.' or 'It was just a mistake. The host will understand this as a cute act of children. Then, let's run away!'
Therefore, as we live in reality, we need to and should think and know our real shape of minds. And in reality, we, human beings are not rational and even justify our behaviors and beliefs for ourselves. So, I'm on an affirmative side of the topic that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs. I'm going to provide two reasons to support my opinion. First, human minds control human bodies in thinking and behaving. Second, humans are innately selfish beings.
Not to misunderstand our mind workings and not to treat our inner world with ignorance, we should know and learn about our self-justification working proved in psychological field according to several results of experiments and studies.

2014년 9월 21일 일요일

Week7 - Research (pictures)





https://www.google.co.kr/search?q=placebo+effect&newwindow=1&biw=1920&bih=979&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=fqsfVI7jMsvM8gW7_4D4Dw&sqi=2&ved=0CD0QsAQ

This is good pictures from Google images search to understand the Placebo effect.


Week7 - First draft - Qs for Narration

My persuasive argument thesis is

People try to justify their behaviors and beliefs in the situation when they do something wrong or unacceptable.

1. What do people already know about my topic?

Everyone knows that human beings are rational in thinking and behaving. Everyone knows that they mostly think in objective ways. We behave like engineers, working accurate, objective, and not mistakable. Some people engage in rational jobs, engineers, doctors, mathematicians, and so on. In the world of rationality, people fear about mistakes. In reality, though, people make something wrong so-called mistakes, and they are worrying about what should they do with that kind of problem. This case, though people are thinking and behaving in rationality, they try to justify their behaviors or beliefs to make themselves feel better, and to keep their positive images of themselves.

2. What research has already been done about my topic?

http://psychology.about.com/od/pindex/f/placebo-effect.htm : this source is a good example of understanding Placebo effect which is necessary to learn human self-justification.


3. What are the implications of my argument? (What if I'm right? What if I'm right and people ignore me?)

People in the world was thought to be in two different ways. First, what I think more acceptable in reality is that humans are subjective beings, judging something by their emotions, personal views or experiences. The other that I do not agree for is that humans are totally rational beings, so that they make judgement according to their objective and direct reason. In the situation of this conflict between two thoughts, researches on human justification of themselves has been done by several scientists and psychologists. People will never get to know how their behaviors and thoughts work unconsciously in their mind operation. Reading my classical argument people will be able to appreciate about their inner workings and psychological effects entailed by them.
Humans will work for making their wrongdoing justified for themselves. Human minds will be incapable of independence from self-justification. Mistakes will occur, humans will need to overcome them, but we will use justification to overcome our wrong behaviors or beliefs. If people ignore me, they will lose their opportunities to be able to know about their inner mind working. They will ignore more and more about their minds which can lead them to live in unrealistic world by justifying everything.

2014년 9월 20일 토요일

Week6 - First draft - Introduction

My Introduction:

Humans reason everyday, every time in their lives. Then, do they reason in objective ways or subjective ways in the case of judging themselves? People often support the idea of first one, because in rapidly changing society of techniques, people should reason in sophisticated and accurate way, no matter the judgement of themselves like a mirror. On the other hand, others argue that people are subjective in seeing themselves because they look themselves as the first person. I wondered whether people judge their behaviors or beliefs objectively or subjectively. People like to take some fun psychological tests for enjoying. However, that does not mean that they are fully interested in learning how their minds are doing and what are the results of their working. I wanted to wake them up from ignorance of their minds, and make them understand their inner operation affecting their behaviors and beliefs. So, I made one question, 'Do people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs?' Justifying one's behavior and beliefs means that one person judges him or herself in subjective way when one made some fault which includes minor things to cruel things. And I stated my opinion to agree with the topic. I believe that people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs when they did something not acceptable or wrong. Before I give you more specific reasons to support my argument, I'll introduce more backgrounds about my topic to let you know what I'm going to persuade you.

2014년 9월 14일 일요일

Week4 - Outline

Outline:

Introduction
attention grabbing by introducing human mind
slightly let readers know about my topic
state my opinion that agrees to the question

Narration
deeply introduce my topic mentioning two conflicting arguments of my topic
offering several philosophers to make readers understand more easily

Confirmation
provide research files to fully support my argument, stating two major reasons

Refutation and Confession
give three possible opposite opinions
refute against what opponents might complain
silently restated my opinion while refuting others

Conclusion
let readers why my argument is important and why mine is more persuasive
finishing the argument, persuading the readers

2014년 9월 10일 수요일

Week3 - Research

Source:

http://psychology.about.com/od/pindex/f/placebo-effect.htm

My topic

Human beings try to justify their behaviors and beliefs


What I hope to learn from this source

I wanted to learn one of example of human self-justification effect that is existing in reality and is affecting human, supported by psychological study.

Notes:

Experiment!!

1. People ate counterfeited drug when they felt sick.
2. Psychologists observed the patients how they would be whether they are getting better or getting worse.
3. As a result, surprisingly, patients got better through they didn't take real drugs!!
4. Therefore, psychologists suggested the idea of Placebo effect, named from one psychologist who took this experiment, if people get better when their mind strongly believe to be so.

Final thought:

Through this effect, I could know that people tend to justify their beliefs and those are also expressed by their behaviors or state.

Week2 - Research

Source

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-justification

My topic

Human beings try to justify their behaviors and beliefs.


What I hope to learn from this source

I hope to learn about the psychological theory of why people try to justify their behaviors and beliefs (esp. cognitive dissonance)

Notes:

 1. inconsistent with our beliefs(cognitive dissonance) -> people feel the need to           justify their beliefs

 2. Internal self-justification refers to a change in the way people perceive their               actions

 3. External self-justification refers to the use of external excuses to justify one's             actions.


Final thought:

This source is so useful so that I can understand the psychological effect of self-justification and cognitive dissonance which are necessary for my writing.